Skip to main content

Our programmers try out the top coding games for kids

We often do round ups of coding apps and games for children at Transcendit, but it's difficult to know how useful these apps are at teaching your kids the real-life skills they need to become programmers.

Are they beneficial? Are they a good way to teach the next generation of programmers? Or are we just all wasting our time, and in some cases, our money?

We decided to find out by putting a bunch of our developers in front of five of the most talked-about 'coding' games for kids. We asked the guys from our Gateshead office to play a game for five minutes with a coding novice (myself), and then give us their thoughts.

Apple Swift Playgrounds

Reviewed by Christophe Duhaut

Apple Swift Playgrounds was unveiled to much fanfare last summer, and if you judge it on its looks alone it scores full marks. If you do sit down and play the game however, you're likely to be disappointed.

'There's too much reading, and it's so slow,' says Christophe. 'Even though its using the correct programming language it doesn't really feel like it's teaching you anything.' We aren't sure exactly how old Apple's target audience is, but the game had us reading some fairly lengthy instructions. We got bored very quickly, and don't think many kids would have the patience to stick with it unsupervised.

Christophe's final thoughts, 'I don't know if its really coding, or if its just teaching you logic. You learn the same things when you play a board game.'

Hopscotch - ★ ★ 

Reviewed by Lee Irving 

Lee and I were also fairly frustrated with Hopscotch. As opposed to written instructions, the tutorial plays alongside your game in the corner of the screen, but unless you have bionic vision it's pretty difficult to follow.

After making a bear spin around and grow a few sizes, the poor usability got in the way of any potential fun and/or learning. We were still struggling with the teeny tiny instructions when the timer indicated our five minutes were up. Lee and I can't see this holding any child's attention long enough to teach them anything. Although, Hopscotch did at least attempt to teach skills beyond sequences.

Lee's final thoughts, 'You'd have to be patient enough to do the tutorials to know whether its worthwhile. It looks ok. But usability is awful.'

Human Resource Machine - ★ ★ 

Reviewed by Paul Callaghan

Paul picked Human Resource Machine, the only game on this list that comes with a price tag (£1.99). By his own admission he did play 'most of the levels' and rated it fairly highly for a 'retro geek puzzle', but poorly as an educational tool.

'It quickly turned into an exercise in really low-level programming. It was more about knowing obscure tricks from assembly language rather than important programming principles. You're also encouraged to "optimise" the code in order to reduce program size or run time, which definitely is not for beginners!'

Paul's final thoughts, 'This wasn't so much of a game as it was a form of torture.'

codeSpark - ★ ★ ★ 

Reviewed by Jonty Davis

codeSpark was a lot easier to understand than its rivals. There were no laborious instructions to read, the game used a cursor to tell you what to do instead. We got a lot of game-play in five minutes, but teaching coding and programming didn't seem like a priority. The levels we did relied on putting actions like run and jump into a sequence.

'It's teaching children that they have to program things in the right sequence, but that's basically it,' says Jonty. 'I don't see that its teaching children any particular coding skills, at least, no more than any other computer game would teach them - you do stuff, there's consequences.'

Jonty's final thoughts, 'I think its aimed at little children. It's certainly not aimed at me.'

Lightbot★ ★ ★ ★ 

Reviewed by Adam McCormick  

Although Lightbot fell into a lot of the same traps that the other games did, it did feel a lot more enjoyable. The usability and interface are good, it's easy to get to grips with and you can start playing straight away. The tutorials and the lessons are combined with game-play, which makes it more palatable than the other apps.

We also packed a lot into five minutes. Lightbot went beyond just learning the basics of sequences and taught you how to use processes and loops; essentially how to abbreviate your code. As a novice, I felt like the lessons were a lot faster than the others, and I was learning a lot more.

Adam's final thoughts, 'You learn about sequences from basic maths, but the processes and loops are useful programming skills. It's pretty good.'

So what's the verdict?

None of us were blown away by these apps. There seems to be a lot of emphasis on teaching children how to understand sequences, which we'd argue they learn anyway by other means.

Paul Callaghan made no secret of his disdain for these kinds of games, 'It's easy enough cobble together some apparently relevant app. It often makes good headlines and publicity, but doesn't necessarily teach useful lessons. It can even be a step backwards for kids if the app encourages the wrong skills.'

Lightbot is definitely our top pick, with a good balance of learning and play and a simple interface that will appeal to both younger and older audiences. It's certainly the only game that this writer would consider returning to. But if your kids turn their noses up at it, Paul says, 'just introduce them to Minecraft.'

Is there something we should be talking about? Tweet us @TranscenditUK


The Transcendit Way

Transcendit understand that when you choose to work with us, whether we're taking care of your IT, app or web development, you're trusting us with part of your business. So whether we're looking after your computers, phone systems or servers we always do things 'the Transcendit way'.

The whole of our team adhere to the same values, beliefs and policies - the principles that were written when Transcendit first formed in 2000. Whether you come to us for cloud services or recovery backup you can be confident that you'll always receive the same excellent service.

The Transcendit way outlines how we do business; following the same straightforward principles with every client and customer, regardless of how big or small they may be.

That means we get to know you and your business. We offer you a friendly, professional and efficient service, and we'll always be honest with you.
We understand that not everybody speaks fluent IT, so we try to explain things in a way that is simple and clear. We always spend as much time as is necessary explaining things to you.
If you need to talk to us about something, no matter how insignificant, we are only ever a phone call away – and we’re never too busy to make you a cup of tea and have a sit down with you in person.
We understand how frustrating it can be when things are late. When we schedule an appointment with you, we are there when you’re expecting us. If something prevents us from getting there, we always call you in advance to let you know.
Sometimes things can go wrong, but we never lie to you or try to cover something up. If things go askew we tell you what’s happened and how we plan to prevent it affecting your business.
We want you to continuously benefit from working with us. We regularly discuss your business and make suggestions for improving systems and processes wherever we can – but we never try to push you into a purchase.
When we quote a fixed price, that's always the amount we charge – you won’t find any nasty surprises on a bill from us. If you are paying by time and materials, we inform you if our approximations could change.
We understand the importance of privacy for your business and your customers. We respect the confidentiality of your data, and we will never pass on your information to third parties.
We appreciate it when you take the time to give us feedback. A system called CustomerSure records our client's responses, so you can trust that our reviews are from real people.
Find out what they're saying here.
The app works perfectly and looks great on both iPhone and Android Victoria Brunton, Hospitality Guaranteed

Based on 9849 reviews our customers rate us 9.8/10. Reviews and ratings by Customersure. 27-August-2021

Transcendit are proud sponsors of CHUF, the Children's Heart Unit Fund.

Transcendit is a Living Wage employer